Follow Zester Daily on Facebook for the latest in food news, cooking tips and healthy eating Follow Zester Daily on Twitter for the latest in food news, cooking tips and healthy eating Subscribe to our Zester Daily RSS Feeds for the latest in food news, cooking tips and healthy eating

Get Back on Track, Slow Food USA Print
Once a vital force in the culture and future of food, Slow Food's American chapter is reduced to tweets.
By Poppy Tooker   |   Monday, 23 January 2012   |   00:39

slow food usa need to get back to its missionA group of former Slow Food USA members, leaders and activists, led by Gary Paul Nabhan, founder of RAFT (Renewing America's Food Traditions), came together this month to create a road map intended to help reverse a trajectory which has distanced the U.S. group from Slow Food's founding principles. The suggestions, 10 Things Slow Food Can Do to See Its Way Into 2012, were sent to the president, Josh Viertel, and the current board and carried the hope that Slow Food USA would redirect it's resources to restore and regain its former position as a leading voice in America's food future.  

Founded in the 1980s by Italian visionary Carlo Petrini,  Slow Food's original mission was to combat the effects of fast-food in our increasingly fast lives. Members were urged to slow down and enjoy the pleasures of the table while actively preserving and promoting heritage foods and the farmers who produce and safeguard them. Petrini's idea caught fire; the Slow Food message took root and flourished in more than 150 countries, including the United States.

More members, less money

In 2008, thousands of Slow Food members gathered in San Francisco for the culinary equivalent of a love-in, dubbed "Slow Food Nation." Viertel had just been named president of the U.S. organization and seemed poised to further invigorate an American audience primed for change in the existing food system. He inherited the message "Good, Clean and Fair," and was tasked with increasing membership, particularly among the youth of America.

While Viertel has succeeded in increasing membership,  the ability of these new members to sustain an expensive Brooklyn office is in question, as evidenced by recent layoffs. The "pay what you want" membership campaign resulted in lots of dollars — single dollar bills, that is, in some cases from longtime members who had previously given at the $60 or $100 level. They were now making a statement about what a Slow Food membership's true worth had become.

Endangered foods left behind

In November 2010, Viertel suspended the activities of Slow Food USA's only standing committee focused on the Ark of Taste, an international project of Slow Food. Using Noah's Ark as a metaphor, these committees -- active in most countries where Slow Food is firmly entrenched -- identify endangered foods with vital cultural ties to a place and, most importantly, are delicious to eat. After the findings pass a review by the national committee, Slow Food International's foundation promotes these foods on their website and at the biannual Terra Madre and Salone del Gusto events in Turin, Italy. Today with the national committee disbanded; there is no way for U.S. foods to be added to the international Ark.

Over the past three years, Slow Food USA has lost touch with its grass-roots base, ignored its principle mission and become too focused on symbolic gestures, often political in nature, which lack any firm outcome.

Member publication discontinued

At one time, an online member publication called the Snail, was filled with reports of real work being done by members across America. It spread Slow Food news and highlights, such as the monumental coast-to-coast Ark of Taste Seed Grow Out, an initiative that helped mainstream near-extinct ingredients like the Jimmy Nardello Frying Pepper, which now frequently appears on restaurant menus. Under Viertel, the Snail ceased publication, and today, Slow Food USA relies almost exclusively on social media bytes centered on musings from the Brooklyn office, rarely mentioning the work of chapter members.

Over the last three years, the Brooklyn staff has experienced a near complete turnover, effectively erasing the cultural memory of the decade-old U.S. organization. New hires at Slow Food USA are eloquent in social justice-styled community activism. but do not speak the language of food or agriculture.

When asked about his accomplishments, Viertel touts the power of Slow Food USA's tweets. Perhaps it's time to put some feet on the street and listen to what the real buzz is all about. As evidenced by recent Slow Food USA's IRS filings, it's more about financial collapse than bee colony collapse. There's a strange brew simmering in that Brooklyn slow cooker.


This week's Zester Soapbox contributor, Poppy Tooker, is the host of NPR affiliated radio show, "Louisiana Eats!" and founded the New Orleans Slow Food chapter in 1999.  Over the next decade, Poppy served as a Slow Food International Governor, was a founding member of the U.S. Ark of Taste committee and was awarded the Carlo Petrini Leadership Award in 2006.  With her motto, "Eat It To Save It," Poppy carries the banner for endangered heirloom fruits and vegetables and heritage breed animals alike.

Photo: Poppy Tooker. Credit: Chris Granger

* * *

Enter now to win one of 10 signed copies of Poppy Tooker's "Crescent City Farmers Market Cookbook."

 

Slow Food USA
Shop Indie Bookstores



smaller | bigger
security image
Write the displayed characters
...
My wife and I , both chefs who met in culinary school are launching our personal crusade this year from New Orleans, La. We are packing up in our airstream trailer to travel the country, put boots on the ground, lend a shovel filled hand to local small time farmers, and blog about it. At the end of the year we will release our cookbook with the recipes from our travel. Thanks Poppy for your part in inspiring us. We hope to be of service to the fair and safe food community. If any of you are interested in following us on the road you can email me at john.spivey.jr@gmail.com and I will add you to the newsletter and blog list.

Regards and good eating,
John
a guest , April 03, 2012
...
I think SF was very good at dinners and education and getting people excited about good food. I don't think they've been so great at politics. I think losing the Ark, which was very much a work in progress, was a huge mistake. I hope they can figure out what to do but as of now, they seem like one of many shrill food politics groups.
a guest , January 27, 2012
...
As a former Ark of Taste member I feel I really must speak up. That it lost (or failed to gain) relevance for some was at least as much a concern for the committee of volunteers who worked tirelessly to bring significance, application and education around biodiversity to collaborators and partners, chapters, members and the public at large. We worked tirelessly to devise and recommend strategies and ideas - some simple and some grand to spread the word and deed of the importance of diverse, culturally significant lost or in danger foods. On the cusp of that work the turnover of the board and staff and therefore redirection of Slow Food principals simply left little support (and I believe desire for support) of these programs let alone for our ideas, strategies and efforts to bring them to applicable life across food stratospheres. It was my experience that the new board and staff (little if any hired with any background in food, agriculture or biodiversity) were actually on their own thinly veiled elitist pursuit shunning many of the principals that once made Slow Food a strong, viable and truly unique organization. Suggestions for making the information and application more relevant and accessible were left unacknowledged or shut down. Simple administration of funds, programs, staff, volunteers, events, information dissemination and PR were grossly under or mismanaged with the excuse seeming to be a perpetual string of interns, staff turnover and literally years of “evaluation and ‘strategic’ planning”. It is my experience in fact, that the word food was very rarely used in the direction of national organizational work. I left the Ark to pursue this work in arenas where its importance is still valued, but before I did, I was able to see that the leadership did not only lack respect for the effort and its significance to our future country and world but for the actual people who gave so much of their time and energy to the slow building and rebuilding of good clean and fair food. As I understand it, things progressed in this way for some time as the committee and programs continued to hold on until they were unceremoniously left to wither without any word whatsoever from the staff or board. I believe this is how it stands today! I don’t know if they intentionally or unintentionally mismanaged or discarded these programs or people but for being absurdly overstaffed (until the recent layoff of half that Brooklyn office), they seemed to be running a three-ring circus down there, I am inclined to believe that they lacked both management capacity and will. Regardless, no, if this administration ever wanted biodiversity they surly had a disgraceful way of showing it.
a guest , January 26, 2012
...
False American pride may be the very reason we are in this situation.

It was never my experience as a leader or chapter member that I enjoyed a twelve course tasting menus under the Tuscan sun. I hear that was a problem in some chapters but here again, that too is a matter of leadership and oversight (volunteer, staff or board). I heard talk of it more then I ever experienced it in either my own chapter or almost any that I visited. IF that was a problem in your chapter, then why did you not stand up? It was my experience that under previous board leadership and under the core values, philosophy and activities of Slow Foods founders, that we created tangible, educational advocacy opportunities across ages and incomes.

I found the “$5.00 challenge” gratuitous and paternalistic; at best a silly effort and at worse a divisive one. Furthermore as sound bites, it was positioned to make the least aware people (and those with the most to learn) believe that food should be cheap – perpetuating the very opposite of “good, clean and fair” for either farmers or eaters.

As a THE industrial country that spends the least share of its dollars on food bringing on a host of insecurities, fast reduction of biodiversity , loss of safe and humane farms and land, perhaps we need to be less American in our thinking about food, food systems, subsidies and the inherent cost of food. I suggest that would be the most relevant (and realistic).

No – The redirections may have been good for Mr. Viertel but four years later, the changes under this boards oversight have not been positive, proactive or in any way tangible for food, for farmers or for eaters.
a guest , January 26, 2012
...
After Hurricane Katrina, the L'Hoste organic citrus farm was saved by its Ark of Taste satsuma. Slow Food USA sent a mass email to let members & friends know that for $25 a box, the L'Hoste family would ship a box of satsumas anywhere in the country in time for Christmas. Hundreds of orders poured in thru my email box and the L'Hostes shipped on the promise that "the check was in the mail" as it was early 2006 before phone lines & internet access was restored to Braithwaite, LA where the orchard is located. The magic of Slow Food folks, was that EVERY CHECK ARRIVED, despite the lack of regular mail service in South Louisiana following Hurricanes Katrina & Rita. One single program cannot make an entire movement - and no one is suggesting that. But the power of keeping heirloom fruit and vegetables and heritage breed animals with close cultural ties to a specific place should not be discounted or disregarded. -- Poppy Tooker
a guest , January 25, 2012
...
The Ark of Taste was doing good work but it was largly irrelevant for all but a very few people. We need support for rare species, sure, lets collect and promote them. But that cannot be the end of our mission. Working on the Ag bill or supporting better national standards for laying hens effect far more people. EVERYONE needs access to GOOD FOOD. You cannot do that by constantly extolling the virtures of the rare Double-billed Purple Duck. We need to improve the entire supply chain. In some cases these goals can go hand in hand, look at the long term success of heritage turkeys ($190 at our local butcher).
a guest , January 25, 2012
...
I think the changes Josh has made are primarily positive. Slow Food needs more, engaged members not just people who enjoy twelve course tasting menus under the Tuscan sun. And frankly, that is what a lot of the old members really wanted. Slow Food often seemed like a group of big thinkers and posh gluttons. We had far more requests for fancy dinners from the old guard than interest in farm tours (unless they included a fancy dinners), garden work parties, or school food events.

I thought the $5 challenge was brilliant. It, coupled with the school gardens program, have invigorated our local community.

I was sorry to see the ark go, but it was really a matter of perception. It seemed so...un-American in it's language. It needs to be reinvented to be more relevant.
a guest , January 25, 2012
...
Thank you Poppy for this cogent synopsis of why the Slow Food board needs to ask its Brooklyn staff to tangibly reconnect with communities, farmers, chefs, home cooks and America's food biodiversity. For anyone who wishes to endorse the Ten Things Slow Food Can Positively Do," see my website www.garynabhan.com & join the ranks of food justice leaders in 20 states who are asking the SFUSA board to revitalize the on-ground efforts that atrophied over the last three years. One more thing: while Brooklyn claims it is helping the honeybee--the larger pollinator crisis affecting hundreds of species essential to our food supply has been going on for 17 years, & Slow has never joined the National Pollinator Partnership, the Wild Farm Alliance nor the Forgotten Pollinator Campaign nor consulted with its own biodiversity experts about native pollinators. See www.pollinator.org, www.wildfarmalliance.org & our Borderlands Habitat Restoration Initiative for pollinators. If Slow is to show it understands collaborative conservation, it must come to the table as equal partners with others rather than pretending that it manages the table.
a guest , January 24, 2012
...
Excellent (and sad!) recap of Slow Food USA, Poppy. Thank you. Without the Ark of Taste and a strong
biodiversity platform Slow Food just doesn't mean what it use to to me. I hope to see that return. Soon!
a guest , January 24, 2012
...
Bravo Poppy,
Promoting food justice involves a lot more than academic/self aggrandizing exercises Slow Food has engaged in these past few years. Unfortunately they have proven that they can not accomplish both without splintering their core message, membership and funding support especially in an arena as crowded as food justice. Unless I have missed something, we hear a lot of rhetoric but don’t see so much activity save for those chapters and members devoted to the original and ongoing Slow Food International vision and mission. Once a uniquely positioned and clearly identified, vibrant organization, unfortunately it doesn’t seem the national organization and its leadership stands for or does much for farmers and eaters anymore.
a guest , January 24, 2012

busy
Last Updated on Monday, 23 January 2012 02:11
 

Zester Daily | Food News | Cooking | Dining Out | Healthy Eating | Wine

Copyright © 2012 Zester LLC.

Site Design & Hosted by digical